|
<div style="padding-left: 1.6em; font-style: italic; border-top: 1px solid #a2a9b1; margin: 0.5em 0; padding-top: 0.5em">The discussion above is closed. <b style="color: #FF0000;">Please do not modify it.</b> Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.</div><!-- from [[Template:Archive bottom]] -->
</div><div style="clear:both;"></div>{{#if:|[[Category:Pages using Rfc top or Rfc bottom with rfcid parameter]]}}
=== RishabhBot ===
I am requesting bot status for my bot [[User:RishabhBot]] as it is needed to move commonly misspelled pages and add archive links. [[رُکُن:Rishabhbhat|Rishabhbhat]]
Proposed tasks:
# Replace bare URLs in references with <code><nowiki>{{cite web}}</nowiki></code>, and add the archive.org link.
# Replace common spelling errors such as the Latin fullstop being used instead of Persian one. Move pages with non-Kashmiri characters like "ۍ".
([[رُکُن بَحَژ:Rishabhbhat|talk]]) ١٣:٥١, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
==== Support====
# '''Support''' as operator [[رُکُن:Rishabhbhat|Rishabhbhat]] ([[رُکُن بَحَژ:Rishabhbhat|talk]]) ١٣:٥١, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
# '''Support''' [[رُکُن:Imranqazi90|Imranqazi90]] ([[رُکُن بَحَژ:Imranqazi90|talk]]) ١٤:٠٣, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
# '''Support''' Archiving is very much needed on this project. I hope you wil be extra cautious while using it as a spell checker. I trust your abilities so, I will support the proposal. Thankyou. [[رُکُن:Iflaq|افلٲق]] ([[رُکُن بَحَژ:Iflaq|talk]]) ١٤:٢٦, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
====Oppose ====
==== Comment ====
It is just me or anyone else who believes the bots shouldn't be running without the approval. The bot has made ~80 edits without being approved/flagged. It has even made edits to the devanagri language pages. Moreover, its task seems to be similar to that of Uhaas bot because Uhaas bot has also made that type of edits recently. --[[User:Hulged|<span style="background:linear-gradient(90deg,crimson,indigo, #ADD8E6); -webkit-background-clip:text !important; -webkit-text-fill-color:transparent;">Hulged</span>]] ([[User talk:Hulged|talk]]) ١٤:٤٩, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
:@[[رُکُن:Hulged|Hulged]] That is right a bot should not make edits until approved. Rishab kindly do not make any further edits till a bot flag has been granted. We must also have a policy about this type of situation. Hope you can frame one with the support of othe users . That is really an eagle eye. [[رُکُن:Iflaq|افلٲق]] ([[رُکُن بَحَژ:Iflaq|talk]]) ١٤:٥٩, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
: (edit conflict) {{ping|Hulged|Iflaq}} I ran the bot to demonstrate the simplest task it would be performing- and arguably the least controversial, as the letters I replaced are not part of the Kashmiri alphabet. If Uhaas bot will perform the spellchecking, I am okay with it, however this one can perform more complicated ones (like replacing Latin fullstops with Kashmiri fullstops, without breaking URLs) as it runs on Python. Also it is fully automatic and needs only be supervised.
: For archiving I don't believe Uhaas Bot is going to be run , but if it is, I will withdraw my application.
: P.S. The Devanagari pages were edited as they erroneously contained Perso-Arabic characters. see the diffs.
: [[رُکُن:Rishabhbhat|Rishabhbhat]] ([[رُکُن بَحَژ:Rishabhbhat|talk]]) ١٥:٠٣, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
::@[[رُکُن:Rishabhbhat|Rishabhbhat]], There is no problem if both the bots run for spell checking owing to the fact that I some times am not available. Uhaas bot is not going to take up archiving task. It just tags pages with maintenance tags and spellchecks pages occassionally. There is no need to withdraw the application, However a bot should only run when approved. Since there is no policy about bots here this is a mistake unknowingly. No need to worry. [[رُکُن:Iflaq|افلٲق]] ([[رُکُن بَحَژ:Iflaq|talk]]) ١٥:٠٩, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
:: {{ping|Iflaq}} Alright. I will not run any more scripts as I was anyways only demonstrating what would be done. [[رُکُن:Rishabhbhat|Rishabhbhat]] ([[رُکُن بَحَژ:Rishabhbhat|talk]]) ١٥:١٤, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
::{{U|Rishabhbhat}}, please list all the tasks that the bot is going to perform, if approved, clearly. It will move the mispelled pages in ks-arab language and archive talk pages? Or it will change latin full stops into Kashmiri ones? I would also like it if bot operators will list the tasks their bots perform on the bot user pages. --[[User:Hulged|<span style="background:linear-gradient(90deg,crimson,indigo, #ADD8E6); -webkit-background-clip:text !important; -webkit-text-fill-color:transparent;">Hulged</span>]] ([[User talk:Hulged|talk]]) ١٥:١٩, ١ سیٚپٹَمبَر ٢٠٢١ (UTC)
====Result====
| 